Wine Review Archive


Robert Parker:

2015 C. C. Ranch Cabernet,
95+ points
December 2017

2015 Element 28 Cabernet,
96 points
December 2017

2015 Hayne Vineyard Cabernet,
94+ points
December 2017

2015 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
94+ points
December 2017

2015 State Ranch Cabernet,
93 points
December 2017

2013 Cabernet Sauvignons,
94-90 points
December 30, 2015

2012 Cabernet Sauvignons,
95-90 points
October 30, 2014

2010 Cabernet Sauvignons,
94-90 points
October 31, 2013

2009 Cabernet Sauvignons,
December 27, 2012

2008 Cabernet Sauvignons,
December 23, 2011

2007 Cabernet Sauvignons,
December 23, 2010

2006 Cabernet Sauvignons,
December 23, 2009


Vinous

2015 C.C. Ranch Cabernet
94 points
March 2018

2015 Element 28 Cabernet
91 points
March 2018

2015 Hayne Vineyard Cabernet
93 points
March 2018

2015 State Ranch Cabernet
95 points
March 2018

2015 John C. Sullenger Vineyard Cabernet
96 points
March 2018

2013 Cabernets
95 points
October 2015


Wine & Spirits:

2013 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
93 points
October 2016

2013 Dragonfly Cabernet,
92 points
October 2016

2013 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
93 points
October 2016

2013 State Ranch Cabernet,
91 points
October 2016

2012 Cabernet Sauvignons,
94-92 points
February 2015

2010 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
92 points
June 2014

2010 Harris Merlot,
92 points
August 2013

2009 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
93 points
December 2012

2009 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
December 2012

2009 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
December 2012

2008 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
December 2011

2008 Kelham Vineyard Cabernet,
December 2011

2007 Harris Vineyard Merlot,
February 2011

2007 Martin Stelling, State
Ranch & John C. Sullenger,
Year’s Best Carbernets,
December 2010

2006 Martin Stelling & Vogt Cabernets,
Year’s Best Cabernets,
December 2010

2006 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
100 Best Wines of the Year,
Winter 2010

2006 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
June 2001


The Palm Beach Post:

Swirl Girls: Summer sampling,
July 23, 2013

Swirl Girls: A round-up of reds:
rubies and garnets galore,
April 9, 2013

Swirl Girls: Wines with a sense of place,
December 4, 2012

Swirl Girls: A SWEET SIP:
Suscol Ranch Merlot,
June 24, 2012

Swirl Girls: Nickel and Nickel wines are money well spent,
April 20, 2011

 

 

Wine Enthusiast:

2015 Hayne Vineyard Cabernet,
92 points
August 2018

2015 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
94 points
July 2018

2015 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
91 points
July 2018

2015 State Ranch Cabernet,
94 points
June 2018

2013 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
91 points
February 2017

2013 Dragonfly Cabernet,
92 points
February 2017

2013 Element 28 Cabernet,
91 points
February 2017

2013 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
91 points
February 2017

2013 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
92 points
February 2017

2013 State Ranch Cabernet,
94 points
February 2017

2012 Cabernets,
95-90 points
May 2015

2012 Suscol Ranch Merlot,
91 points
February 2015w

2010 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
94 points
December 2013

2010 Branding Iron Cabernet,
93 points
December 2013

2010 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
92 points
December 2013

2010 Hayne Cabernet,
92 points
December 2013

2010 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
92 points
December 2013

2010 Harris Merlot,
95 points
July 2013

2010 Suscol Ranch Merlot,
90 points
July 2013

2009 Cabernet Scores,
November 2012

2009 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
November 2012

2009 Branding Iron Cabernet,
November 2012

2009 State Ranch Cabernet,
November 2012

2009 Harris Merlot,
September 2012

2009 Suscol Ranch Merlot,
September 2012

2010 Truchard Chardonnay,
September 2012

2009 Darien Syrah,
September 2012

2006 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
2006 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
2006 Vogt Cabernet,
2006 State Lane Ranch Cabernet,
March 2010


Wine Spectator:

2015 C.C. Ranch,
90 points
2018

2015 Stiling Chardonnay,
91 points
June 15, 2017

2015 High-Line Chardonnay,
91 points
June 15, 2017

2013 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
91 points
November 30, 2016

2013 Dragonfly Cabernet,
91 points
November 30, 2016

2013 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
91 points
November 30, 2016

2012 Hayne Cabernet,
90 points
July 13, 2015

2010 Branding Iron Cabernet,
91 points
November 15, 2013

2010 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
92 points
November 15, 2013

2010 Hayne Cabernet,
90 points
November 15, 2013

2010 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
92 points
Web Only – 2013

2009 Darien Syrah,
94 points
May 16, 2012

2009 Darien Syrah,
May 16, 2012

2007 State Ranch Cabernet,
90 points
November 15, 2010

2006 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
91 points
April 30, 2010

2006 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
90 points
February 10, 2010

2007 State Ranch Cabernet,
November 15, 2010

2006 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
April 30, 2010

2006 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
February 10, 2010


San Francisco Chronicle
2009 Harris Merlot,
April 1, 2012

Bigger Than Your Head
2010 Truchard Chardonnay,
April 15, 2012

Bon Appetit
2007 Vogt Cabernet,
February 2011

SF Gate
2007 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
November 28, 2010

Bigger Than Your Head
2007 Darien Syrah,
July 31, 2010

Additional Reviews

Wine Review Online
2010 Sullenger Cabernet,
November 26, 2013

Wine Review Online
2010 Branding Iron Cabernet,
November, 2013

Wine Review Online
2012 Martin Stelling Cabernet Sauvignon
November 18, 2014

Wine Review Online
2012 C.C. Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon
November 11, 2014

Wine Review Online
2009 Harris Merlot,
April 3, 2012

Forbes
2005 Suscol Ranch Merlot,
November 7, 2014

Robert Whitley
2009 Hayne Cabernet,
March 10, 2013

Robert Whitley
2009 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
January 3, 2013

Robert Whitley
Whitley on Wine,
July 2011

James Suckling
2015 Bear Flat Merlot,
93 points
May 2018

2015 Suscol Ranch Merlot,
92 points
May 2018

2015 State Ranch Cabernet,
94 points
December 21, 2017

2015 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
93 points
December 21, 2017

2015 Hayne Vineyard Cabernet,
93 points
December 21, 2017

2015 Element 28 Cabernet,
91 points
December 21, 2017

2015 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
93 points
December 21, 2017

2015 Truchard Chardonnay,
92 points
March 20, 2017

2013 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
95 points
May 3, 2016

2013 Dragonfly Cabernet,
95 points
May 3, 2016

2013 Element 28 Cabernet,
91 points
May 3, 2016

2013 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
91 points
May 3, 2016

2013 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
94 points
May 3, 2016

Restaurant Wine
2013 Truchard Vineyard Chardonnay,
2013 Stiling Vineyard Chardonnay,
5-4 stars
Issue #160, 161 & 162

2012 Harris Vineyard Merlot,
2012 Suscol Ranch Merlot,
4-4+ stars
Issue #160, 161 & 162

2012 Darien Vineyard Syrah,
5 stars
Issue #160, 161 & 162

Vinography
2012 Harris Merlot
Score: between 8.5 and 9
June 2015

The Tasting Panel Magazine
2012 Martin Stelling Cabernet Sauvignon
95 points
February 2015

Stephan Tanzer’s
International Wine Cellar
2010 Cabernet Sauvignons,
90-93+
August 2014

Vinography
2012 Hayne Cabernet,
Score: between 9 and 9.5

2012 State Ranch Cabernet,
Score: between 9 and 9.5

2012 Martin Stelling Cabernet,
Score: around 9
January 11, 2015

2012 Suscol Ranch Cabernet,
Score: between 9 and 9.5

2012 John C. Sullenger Cabernet,
Score: around 9

2012 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
Score: between 9 and 9.5
December 27, 2014

2010 C.C. Ranch Cabernet,
Score: around 9
May 10, 2014

2010 Stelling Cabernet,
Score: between 9 and 9.5

2010 Hayne Cabernet,
Score: around 9.5

2010 Sullenger Cabernet,
Score: between 9 and 9.5.
January 4, 2014

Jeb Dunnuck
2015 Hayne Vineyard Cabernet,
95 points
December 2017

2015 Element 28,
93 points
December 2017

2015 State Ranch,
93 points
December 2017